You know what really grinds my gears? When people talk about football like it’s just Messi vs Ronaldo, Mbappé highlights, and whatever Haaland ate for breakfast. Don’t get me wrong—those guys are generational. But if you weren’t outside watching the ACTUAL game every week, you missed some absolute magicians who never got their flowers. These are the players who made your favorite players look good, the ones who carried teams on their backs without a Ballon d’Or shortlist invite, and the ones FIFA ratings absolutely disrespected. Let’s set the record straight.
Michael Carrick — The Metronome Nobody Appreciated Until He Retired
Honestly, if you didn’t rate Carrick, you didn’t understand football—simple as. While everyone was busy gassing up Gerrard and Lampard (both class, no debate), Carrick was quietly running Manchester United’s midfield like a symphony conductor in a headband. This man dictated tempo, recycled possession, and made defending look like chess.
The problem? He wasn’t flashy. No Hollywood assists, no screamers from 30 yards. Just pure, unadulterated football IQ. Sir Alex Ferguson knew what he had, but the media? Crickets. Even England managers kept benching him for more “dynamic” options. Meanwhile, United won five Premier League titles with Carrick pulling the strings. Put some respect on his name.
Javier Mascherano — The Pitbull Who Did Everyone’s Dirty Work
If you think of Mascherano and only remember that Champions League semifinal when he blocked everything with his face, you’re not wrong—but you’re missing the full picture. El Jefecito was the definition of a midfield destroyer. Liverpool, Barcelona, Argentina—wherever he went, he made defensive midfield look like an art form.
At Barça, he even reinvented himself as a center-back and absolutely bossed it. Not the tallest, not the fastest, but scrappy as hell and smarter than 90% of attackers. While Messi was winning Ballon d’Ors, Mascherano was the one winning the ball back in the first place. Criminally underrated, and honestly, Argentina doesn’t reach those World Cup finals without him.
Thomas Müller — The Raumdeuter Who Broke Football
Here’s the thing with Müller—he doesn’t look like a footballer. Runs like a baby giraffe, first touch occasionally questionable, and yet somehow, somehow, he’s one of the most effective players of this century. Why? Because football isn’t FIFA Ultimate Team, and Müller understood the game on a level most mortals can’t comprehend.
Bayern Munich and Germany built systems around him because he’s a genius at being in the right place at the right time. Over 400 goals + assists for Bayern, World Cup Golden Boot, Champions League winner. But because he doesn’t do stepovers or score bangers for the Instagram algorithm, casual fans slept on him. Big mistake. Müller is proof that football IQ > pace and dribbling stats.
Luka Modrić — The Little Maestro Who Finally Got His Dues (But Way Too Late)
Okay, okay—Modrić won a Ballon d’Or in 2018, so technically he’s not underrated anymore. But let’s be real: that award came after years of people acting like he was just “a good midfielder.” This man spent a decade running Real Madrid’s midfield, winning five Champions Leagues, and making 40-yard passes look casual.
Before the Ballon d’Or, the disrespect was wild. People really tried to say he wasn’t top tier because he didn’t score enough goals. Brother, he’s a midfielder—his job is to make everyone else score. Croatia doesn’t reach a World Cup final without him. Real Madrid doesn’t dominate Europe without him. The fact it took until he was 33 to get proper recognition is criminal.
Sergio Busquets — “You Watch the Game, You Don’t See Busquets”
Vicente del Bosque said it best: “You watch the game, you don’t see Busquets. You watch Busquets, you see the whole game.” If that doesn’t sum up how underrated this guy was, nothing will. While Xavi and Iniesta were getting all the love (deserved, tbf), Busquets was the one making tiki-taka actually work.
He’s not fast, he’s not physical, and he definitely wasn’t doing Cruyff turns every match. But his positioning, his passing, his ability to break up attacks before they even started? Unmatched. Barcelona’s dominance, Spain’s World Cup and Euros—all built on Busquets doing the boring stuff brilliantly. One of the most intelligent defensive midfielders ever, and people still debate if he’s world-class. Madness.
Nemanja Vidić — The Serbian Tank Who Terrorized Strikers
Listen, if you played striker in the Premier League between 2006 and 2014, you had nightmares about Vidić. This man was an absolute monster—aggressive, fearless, and harder to get past than a brick wall covered in barbed wire. Partnered with Rio Ferdinand, he formed one of the best CB pairings the Prem has ever seen.
Yet somehow, when people talk about the best defenders of this era, Vidić doesn’t always get mentioned. Maybe it’s because he wasn’t “elegant” like Ramos or a ball-playing CB like Piqué. But defending isn’t always pretty—it’s about stopping goals. And Vidić? He stopped everything. Five Premier League titles, a Champions League, and countless strikers sent back to the shadow realm. Respect the legend.
Phillip Lahm — The Full-Back Who Could Do Everything
Lahm is one of those players where, if you know ball, you know. But casual fans? They probably slept. Why? Because he was the ultimate professional—consistent, intelligent, versatile—but never the flashiest player on the pitch. You wouldn’t see him in a Neymar highlight reel, but Bayern Munich and Germany trusted him with the captain’s armband for a reason.
Right-back, left-back, even defensive midfield—Lahm could play anywhere and dominate. World Cup winner, eight Bundesliga titles, a Champions League. Not bad for someone who was “too small” early in his career. The man retired at 33 still at the top of his game because he had nothing left to prove. Underrated? Absolutely. Underappreciated? Not by anyone who actually watched him play.
Bonus: The “If You Know, You Know” Tier
Let’s rapid-fire some other absolute ballers who deserve their roses:
Yaya Touré — When he decided to turn up, unstoppable. Man City’s title wins don’t happen without his 2013-14 season.
David Silva — El Mago ran the Prem for a decade but never got the global hype he deserved.
Andrea Pirlo — Some people know, but not enough people. The beard, the vision, the Panenkas—poetry.
Franck Ribéry — Would’ve won a Ballon d’Or if not for that 2013 Ronaldo campaign. Robbery at its finest.
Petr Čech — Best goalkeeper of the 2000s, and it’s not even close. That helmet was iconic for a reason.
The Verdict: Football Isn’t Just About the Highlight Reel
Here’s the truth bomb: the most underrated footballers of the 21st century are underrated because they don’t fit the TikTok algorithm. No rainbow flicks, no 50-goal seasons, no Ballon d’Or campaigns funded by PR teams. Just pure, unfiltered excellence—week in, week out.
These players won trophies, defined eras, and made everyone around them better. They’re the reason your favorite teams succeeded, even if they never got the Instagram followers or the Nike commercials. So next time someone asks you about the greats of modern football and only mentions the obvious names, educate them. Show them this list. Make them put respect on these legends’ names.
Think you know your football? Test yourself on Certified Casual’s latest quizzes and see if you’re really as clued up as you think!